AMMI model in the analysis of genotype by environment interaction of conventionally and organically grown onion
2016
Authors
Brdar-Jokanović, MilkaGirek, Zdenka
Ugrinović, Milan
Sikora, Vladimir
Dalović, Ivica
Zdravković, Jasmina
Article (Published version)
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
This study was aimed to assess the stability of direct yield components (bulb weight and number plot-1) and other yield contributing characteristics (bulb diameter, height and index, neck diameter and length, plant height, emergence and vegetation period) in five commercial onion cultivars grown in conventional and organic environments, by employing additive main effect and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) statistical model in data analysis. The two-year field trial organized in complete randomized blocks included the plots maintained in four regimes: mineral fertilization (conventional), without fertilization, fertilization with farmyard manure and with bacterial fertilizer (organic). Each treatment by year combination was considered as an environment. Analysis of variance of AMMI model calculated for the investigated traits showed that all sources of variation (genotypes, environments, genotype by environment interaction) were highly significant. The largest proportions of the total... sum of squares were encompassed by environments, except for emergence and bulb index with the pronounced effect of genotypes (67.26 and 52.54%, respectively) and neck length with the genotype by environment interaction amounting 44.59%. Generally, the effects of the interactions were in the common range. The AMMI model with two axes was concluded as the best model for the investigated traits. Onions grown in conventional system outperformed the organic ones. However, good performance of the genotypes was accompanied with low stability across the environments and vice versa. Therefore breeding programs intended to develop cultivars adapted to alternative production systems should rely on the experiments set in the corresponding environments that include various combinations of genotypes and agro-technical procedures based on the principles of organic agriculture.
Keywords:
AMMI analysis / genotype by environment interaction / onion / organic agricultureSource:
Genetika, 2016, 48, 3, 1027-1038Publisher:
- Društvo genetičara Srbije, Beograd
Funding / projects:
- Integrating biotechnology approach in breeding vegetable crops for sustainable agricultural systems (RS-31059)
DOI: 10.2298/GENSR1603027B
ISSN: 0534-0012
WoS: 000392920900019
Scopus: 2-s2.0-85014125845
Collections
Institution/Community
Institut za povrtarstvoTY - JOUR AU - Brdar-Jokanović, Milka AU - Girek, Zdenka AU - Ugrinović, Milan AU - Sikora, Vladimir AU - Dalović, Ivica AU - Zdravković, Jasmina PY - 2016 UR - http://RIVeC.institut-palanka.rs/handle/123456789/182 AB - This study was aimed to assess the stability of direct yield components (bulb weight and number plot-1) and other yield contributing characteristics (bulb diameter, height and index, neck diameter and length, plant height, emergence and vegetation period) in five commercial onion cultivars grown in conventional and organic environments, by employing additive main effect and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) statistical model in data analysis. The two-year field trial organized in complete randomized blocks included the plots maintained in four regimes: mineral fertilization (conventional), without fertilization, fertilization with farmyard manure and with bacterial fertilizer (organic). Each treatment by year combination was considered as an environment. Analysis of variance of AMMI model calculated for the investigated traits showed that all sources of variation (genotypes, environments, genotype by environment interaction) were highly significant. The largest proportions of the total sum of squares were encompassed by environments, except for emergence and bulb index with the pronounced effect of genotypes (67.26 and 52.54%, respectively) and neck length with the genotype by environment interaction amounting 44.59%. Generally, the effects of the interactions were in the common range. The AMMI model with two axes was concluded as the best model for the investigated traits. Onions grown in conventional system outperformed the organic ones. However, good performance of the genotypes was accompanied with low stability across the environments and vice versa. Therefore breeding programs intended to develop cultivars adapted to alternative production systems should rely on the experiments set in the corresponding environments that include various combinations of genotypes and agro-technical procedures based on the principles of organic agriculture. PB - Društvo genetičara Srbije, Beograd T2 - Genetika T1 - AMMI model in the analysis of genotype by environment interaction of conventionally and organically grown onion EP - 1038 IS - 3 SP - 1027 VL - 48 DO - 10.2298/GENSR1603027B ER -
@article{ author = "Brdar-Jokanović, Milka and Girek, Zdenka and Ugrinović, Milan and Sikora, Vladimir and Dalović, Ivica and Zdravković, Jasmina", year = "2016", abstract = "This study was aimed to assess the stability of direct yield components (bulb weight and number plot-1) and other yield contributing characteristics (bulb diameter, height and index, neck diameter and length, plant height, emergence and vegetation period) in five commercial onion cultivars grown in conventional and organic environments, by employing additive main effect and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) statistical model in data analysis. The two-year field trial organized in complete randomized blocks included the plots maintained in four regimes: mineral fertilization (conventional), without fertilization, fertilization with farmyard manure and with bacterial fertilizer (organic). Each treatment by year combination was considered as an environment. Analysis of variance of AMMI model calculated for the investigated traits showed that all sources of variation (genotypes, environments, genotype by environment interaction) were highly significant. The largest proportions of the total sum of squares were encompassed by environments, except for emergence and bulb index with the pronounced effect of genotypes (67.26 and 52.54%, respectively) and neck length with the genotype by environment interaction amounting 44.59%. Generally, the effects of the interactions were in the common range. The AMMI model with two axes was concluded as the best model for the investigated traits. Onions grown in conventional system outperformed the organic ones. However, good performance of the genotypes was accompanied with low stability across the environments and vice versa. Therefore breeding programs intended to develop cultivars adapted to alternative production systems should rely on the experiments set in the corresponding environments that include various combinations of genotypes and agro-technical procedures based on the principles of organic agriculture.", publisher = "Društvo genetičara Srbije, Beograd", journal = "Genetika", title = "AMMI model in the analysis of genotype by environment interaction of conventionally and organically grown onion", pages = "1038-1027", number = "3", volume = "48", doi = "10.2298/GENSR1603027B" }
Brdar-Jokanović, M., Girek, Z., Ugrinović, M., Sikora, V., Dalović, I.,& Zdravković, J.. (2016). AMMI model in the analysis of genotype by environment interaction of conventionally and organically grown onion. in Genetika Društvo genetičara Srbije, Beograd., 48(3), 1027-1038. https://doi.org/10.2298/GENSR1603027B
Brdar-Jokanović M, Girek Z, Ugrinović M, Sikora V, Dalović I, Zdravković J. AMMI model in the analysis of genotype by environment interaction of conventionally and organically grown onion. in Genetika. 2016;48(3):1027-1038. doi:10.2298/GENSR1603027B .
Brdar-Jokanović, Milka, Girek, Zdenka, Ugrinović, Milan, Sikora, Vladimir, Dalović, Ivica, Zdravković, Jasmina, "AMMI model in the analysis of genotype by environment interaction of conventionally and organically grown onion" in Genetika, 48, no. 3 (2016):1027-1038, https://doi.org/10.2298/GENSR1603027B . .